Straight Talk
BRIAN LILLEY - Turning a blind eye: Elections Canada gives a shrug of the shoulders to leftie antics

Ken Dryden pauses while outlining his platform during the Liberal leadership race at a news conference in Ottawa September 5, 2006.

Credits: FILE PHOTO

BRIAN LILLEY | QMI AGENCY

Did you hear about Elections Canada investigators busting down Ken Dryden's door with the help of the RCMP this week?

Neither did I, and chances are it will never happen, even though Dryden and three other former Liberal leadership candidates are now in violation of the Elections Act. Dryden, Joe Volpe, Hedy Fry and Martha Hall Findlay have failed to pay back their campaign debts from the 2006 Liberal leadership race despite more than five-and-a-half years of fundraising and two extensions.

The campaign debt should have been paid off by the middle of 2008. Back then, several other Liberals, including then-leader Stephane Dion, Gerard Kennedy and others, still had debts to pay. Rather than apply the law with an even hand, Elections Canada offered an extension rather than prosecution.

Now compare that to their treatment of Conservatives. In April 2008. Canada's "non-partisan" elections watchdog raided Conservative Party headquarters as part of a criminal investigation. The Conservatives took a different interpretation of how advertising could be bought and paid for on a campaign and had already taken Elections Canada to court to get a definitive ruling on the matter.

Then there was the kid glove treatment they gave to the NDP over a donations scam. In the wake of Jack Layton's death, the NDP asked for donations to the Broadbent Institute, a left-wing think-tank set up by a number of people associated with the party. The party was actually promising a 75% charitable tax credit, even though the institute still wasn't set up and did not have charitable status. The NDP was essentially renting out their charity number in violation of the law.

Their punishment? Nothing. They simply had to stop giving out tax receipts and offer refunds to people who felt duped. Do you think that would work if I robbed a bank or collected money for false investments?

Elections Canada has a spotty record on enforcement, one that runs on partisan lines. In the 2011 election, they turned a blind eye to clearly partisan third-party activity by the alleged charity known as Environmental Defence. The group, fronted by Rick Smith, took issue with statements from Environment Minister Peter Kent. Smith promised to run ads, make phone calls and knock on doors - in all, he promised to contact 50,000 homes in Kent's riding of Thornhill, Ont. Despite what was clearly partisan work aimed at unseating a candidate, Environmental Defence never registered as a third party as required by law. The result: A shrug of the shoulders from Elections Canada.

In 2008 a group out of New York City called Avaaz ran ads targeting several Conservative candidates; they wanted them replaced as NDP, Liberal or Green MPs. Ads that ran in Halifax newspapers were claimed as expenses for B.C. ridings, among other irregularities. In the group's American tax filing, they claimed to have spent $137,724 on Canadian political activity while Avaaz claimed just $57,733.83 in their filing to Elections Canada.

A complaint was launched; nothing was done. "Elections Canada does not and cannot monitor day to day advertising expenses incurred during and elections campaign," reads a document put out by Elections Canada.

Funny though, they seem to be able to monitor and prosecute Conservative advertising.

 

Sun News Videos

Brian Lilley on Battleground Ontario and Quebec

Brian Lilley joins David Akin to discuss the the political scenes in Quebec and Ontario.


Horwath and Wynne lead in popularity

The Liberal and NDP leaders are the most popular in Ontario while Tim Hudak, the PC leader, lags behind.


Quebecers throw darts at the Queen

Quebecers threw darts at pictures of the Queen as part of a Patriots Day event.

Ezra Levant’s The Source is the most provocative and thought-changing multimedia show in Canada.

This show is 100% focused on the political battles taking place across Canada, in the United States...even around the world.

Michael Coren brings you strong, balanced opinions to challenge conventional thinking.

Canada’s ‘everyman’ moves beyond the mainstream to search out the most interesting talkable topics in the world.

Byline brings you the stories you won’t hear anywhere else while exploring points of view that are all too often ignored.